Selling Paintings and Prints From a Washington, DC Estate: Estate Sale, Auction or Consignment?

The easiest way to handle a house full of art is to split it three ways. Decorative pieces stay for the estate sale, signed work by a known artist goes to auction, and the few in-between pieces can go on consignment.

If you’re working out how to sell art from an estate in Washington, DC, don’t take anything down yet. Paintings get scratched, mixed up, or tossed when people start moving them before anyone’s had a look.

How to Tell an Original Painting From a Print

Flip each piece over and look at the back first, then check the bottom margin on the prints. An original, a limited-edition print, and a reproduction all go to different buyers, so it helps to know which one you’ve got.

Numbered prints are the easy ones. The Tate says an edition of 25 gets numbered 1/25, 2/25, and so on, usually with the artist’s signature next to it.

You might also see AP on a print. That stands for artist’s proof, an extra print made for the artist outside the numbered run.

A print of a painting is a reproduction, not an original print. That’s okay, since reproductions sell too, just to a different crowd.

On a painting, look for a signature, a gallery label, or an old exhibition sticker. If you find receipts or letters about where a piece came from, keep them with it.

When Paintings and Prints Sell Best at the Estate Sale

Honestly, most decorative framed art does best right at the estate sale with a price tag on it. Think reproductions, framed posters, botanical and map prints, and paintings by hobby artists nobody’s heard of.

Estate sale shoppers love being able to see a piece on the wall and walk out with it. Sending it to auction instead means handling, photos, and a listing, and a modest print usually doesn’t bring enough to cover that.

Big frames do well here too. The buyer takes it off the wall and carries it out, and nobody has to crate it.

When to Send Paintings and Prints to an Estate Sale Auction

If the artist has a real following, a signed original or a numbered print usually belongs at auction, since that’s where the bidders are. Art is one of the main categories we take to auction, along with jewelry, silver, and coins.

An auction with us starts with a walk-through, or sometimes we just look at photos you send. Then we sort out what goes to auction, what sells at the house, and what gets donated.

We catalog and photograph each piece going to auction, write it up, and group it into lots for our buyers. We set opening bids and use a reserve when it makes sense, and you see the plan before anything gets listed.

A lot of families split it. The art goes out to be photographed properly, the furniture and kitchen sell at the house, and our guide to picking an onsite or offsite estate auction explains how that works.

When Consignment Makes Sense for Estate Art

Consignment is the middle path. It suits a piece that deserves a patient sale but doesn’t need a full auction, like a nice framed print or a matching pair of paintings that would look better on a shop floor than in a crowded sale weekend.

Our consignment shop takes artwork along with other collectibles. Up front, you’ll get a written agreement covering how pricing works, what percentage you earn, and when you get paid.

The downside is the wait. A consigned piece can sit for weeks or even months, so we’d only use it for a handful of pieces, never every frame in the house.

Protecting Paintings and Prints Before They Sell

Leave the art in the main rooms until it sells, and keep it out of direct sun. For anything on paper, the Library of Congress suggests a cool, fairly dry spot that doesn’t swing a lot, and it says to keep things out of attics, basements, and anywhere that might leak.

It also says no tape, rubber bands, or glue on paper. If you want to leave a note about a piece, put it on a separate sheet rather than taping it to the frame.

And please don’t throw out a tired old frame or a dusty print. Our list of things families throw away before an estate sale shows how often the clutter pile turns out to have buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I sell inherited paintings online myself?

You can, as long as you’re up for the photos, the buyer questions, the payments, and the shipping. When we run the auction, we handle billing, payment, and pickup or shipping for you.

Do auction buyers come to the house to see the paintings?

Only for an onsite auction. With an offsite auction, we pick the paintings and prints up first, so no buyer ever walks through your front door.

Is a signed print the same as an original painting?

No. A signed print is still a print, either one the artist made from a plate or stone, or a copy of a painting, and those two sell to very different buyers.

Can family keep some of the art before the sale?

Yes, just decide before anything gets cataloged. Put the pieces the family wants in one room and close the door, so nothing ends up at auction or on the sale floor by accident.

Get Help Selling Paintings and Prints in Washington

Sorting a whole house of art goes a lot easier when someone’s done it plenty of times before. iStuffSellers has worked with DC-area families since 2011, and we’re licensed, bonded, and insured.

Our estate sale auction team handles the cataloging, photos, and buyer outreach for anything that belongs at auction. Call 301-401-6688, and Darren Hahnfeld will walk the house with you and help sort what goes to the sale, what goes to auction, and what goes on consignment.

About The Author